dígame si usted prefiere el comentario que estar en español solamente. Soy demasiado oxidada, así que usar traductores.
Hi SHANS ! Haven't seen it on STK yet so i'll comment here.
Main issue of it is your total time: more than 5 minutes is, most of the time, a ranking suicide for an ic. Most edits in less than 3 minutes (max 3:30) in order to be sure to finish, and be able to perfect/change some transitions and scenes. and after 4 minutes, people tend to get bored unless you have a legendary story or rythm which isn't the case (yet !
)
.
As for the anime mix, actually i think there's something interesting to be made with both: Like... the medieval sceneries of berserk and rivalry kinda looks like Alucard's past (Tepes III wars and all). But the problem is you alternate between them without actual connection or coherence. It would have been epic if you kept Hellsing only for the end (and maybe at beginning in order to make a flashback in berserk) insted of random interventions like i saw, IMO. Like: giving the impression Guts is an Alucard's ancestor (maybe because he got cursed by demons or the family he killed ?) and Griffith a creator of Iscariote Section of Vatican ? Honestly it would have been a bit difficult, but in a 3 min vid, it would have got a lot more coherence and originality.
As for technique, i wasn't a big fan of your double screen masks (like at 3:17) and some zooms felt a bit forced ( i suggest adding radial blur when zooming, to give a more fluid effect and hide a bit of the scalled pixels). In the middle, your paper burn portrait were an interesting risk (like from 2:40 o 2:50, showing who's hidden behind the armor adds something nice), but it remains a bit too long, as the other portrait-less burned papers don't have relevant beat sync and seems "just here for adding something". but i liked the effort and mixes of layers/fx. unperfect, but kinda fun to watch. As for rythm: the chorus are a lot less of impact and intensity than verses (the fight Guts vs the mercenary girl have very long scenes, like when she goes down), i dunno if it was intentionnl, but the contrary would have been more natural.
That sums it up: Interesting association and mix, but big length, strange rythm and pace of scenes, inconsistent masks and lack of coherence lost it a bit for me. Yet, I noticed a good effort on it, and some sequences were kinda nice.
Good luck for the IC, and waiting for your next AMV in a bigger time span.
Miér 20 Mar 2024, 7:57 pm por tordo02
» Pedidos de [Anime RAW] Aquì
Sáb 09 Mar 2024, 12:59 am por Jurget
» [RAW][WU] Dr.Slump (243/243) [Completa]
Sáb 09 Mar 2024, 12:58 am por Jurget
» Fate/Zero [BD 720/1080p]
Vie 10 Nov 2023, 3:55 pm por ricksue93@gmail.com
» Jim Kaposztas: El primer editor de AMV
Dom 05 Nov 2023, 11:40 pm por TritioAFB
» Boku no Hero Academia 1080p [BD]
Lun 23 Oct 2023, 3:24 pm por HoSanti
» Bleach 720p [BD]
Vie 06 Oct 2023, 8:43 pm por Wolf64
» Watamote [BD-1080p]
Lun 28 Ago 2023, 12:24 am por rigarz85
» Mas alla de LinkinBall Z: una historia de los Anime Music Video
Lun 31 Jul 2023, 7:02 pm por D2X
» One Piece 1-516 (Cat / Jap DVD-Rip / HDTV) MP4 Descarga directa
Lun 17 Jul 2023, 1:55 pm por armandokaza
» Kurumi Tokisaki Edit - Masquerade - AMV - [ Date A Live IV ] | Neolitz
Sáb 04 Mar 2023, 9:59 pm por Neolitz
» Densetsu Drifters-LDZ
Mar 17 Ene 2023, 10:25 pm por Densetsuldz
» ¿Qué tal gente?
Miér 28 Dic 2022, 1:10 am por CacoVenom
» ¡Hola de nuevo!
Sáb 24 Dic 2022, 10:41 pm por TritioAFB
» [[Time Out]] EdiCión anthy and Joskua [[YuriAmv]] ▶PremIO》 free IC◀
Miér 07 Dic 2022, 2:41 pm por ZeroTM
» [AMV] - Catch Me If You Can - Kaguya-sama: Love Is War
Miér 07 Dic 2022, 1:27 pm por ZeroTM